AMBER AND ANTHONY were drinking coffee together. SHAYLA CAUGHT THEM
It was supposed to be an ordinary Tuesday morning. Shayla woke up early, still exhausted from another restless night, her mind tangled in worries about Anthony’s recent distance. He had been acting strange—late-night phone calls, vague excuses, and mysterious absences that left her questioning everything.
She told herself not to jump to conclusions. Maybe it was work stress. Maybe he was overwhelmed with life. But deep down, Shayla knew something didn’t feel right.
So when her best friend texted her a simple message—“You might wanna check out the café on 5th. Anthony’s there. And he’s not alone.”—her heart sank.
The Discovery
The café on 5th was Anthony’s favorite morning spot. Small, quiet, tucked away from the city’s chaos. He’d always said it was “his place to think.” Shayla never imagined he’d bring another woman there.
But as she approached the fogged-up window, her worst fears came to life.
There, in the corner booth by the window, sat Anthony. And across from him, smiling softly, stirring her cappuccino with delicate precision, was Amber.
Shayla froze outside the glass, her breath catching in her throat.
Anthony leaned in as he spoke, his expression relaxed, almost... happy. A sight Shayla hadn’t seen from him in weeks. Amber laughed quietly, brushing her hair behind her ear in a way that made Shayla’s stomach twist.
For a moment, Shayla thought about walking away. Pretending she never saw it. Maybe ignorance really was bliss.
But then something snapped.
The Confrontation
She pushed open the café door with more force than necessary, the bell overhead ringing sharply. Heads turned. Conversations paused. But Shayla had eyes only for the two people at the corner table.
Anthony looked up, his smile vanishing the instant he saw her. Amber froze, her coffee cup mid-air.
“Well, this looks cozy,” Shayla said, her voice dripping with sarcasm. She walked straight to their table, her heels clicking against the tile floor.
“Shayla—this isn’t what it looks like,” Anthony began, standing as if that would somehow diffuse the situation.
“Oh, please,” Shayla shot back, crossing her arms. “Do you think I’m blind? Or just stupid?”
Amber placed her cup down carefully, forcing calm. “Shayla, this is a public place. We were just having coffee.”
Shayla turned to her, her eyes narrowing. “Funny, because I can’t remember the last time you and I sat down for coffee after everything you’ve done.”
Anthony sighed, running a hand through his hair. “We’re talking, that’s it. Trying to clear the air.”
“Clear the air?” Shayla scoffed. “Why didn’t you tell me you were meeting her? Or is lying your new hobby?”
The entire café had gone silent, patrons pretending not to listen while hanging on every word.
Amber spoke again, quieter this time. “Shayla, you and I both know there’s been tension between all of us. Anthony thought if we talked, maybe we could stop all this fighting.”
Shayla let out a dry laugh. “Oh, so this is a peace talk? Over croissants and cappuccinos? How thoughtful.”
Anthony stepped forward, his voice softer. “I didn’t tell you because I knew how it would look. But I didn’t want to lie to you anymore. Amber and I... we have history, yes. But this was about trying to move past it. For Kai. For all of us.”
The mention of Kai’s name hit Shayla like a punch to the chest. Her son deserved peace, sure—but did that mean sitting across from the woman who helped tear their family apart?
What Shayla Did Next
But instead of screaming, instead of causing the scene everyone in the café was bracing for, Shayla took a deep breath.
“You know what?” she said, her voice steady but cold. “If you two want to sit here and play house, be my guest. I won’t stop you.”
She looked directly at Anthony. “But don’t expect me to be waiting when you come home. I won’t share my life with someone who makes side plans without me.”
And to Amber, she added, “Enjoy your coffee. I hope it tastes as bitter as this moment feels.”
With that, she turned and walked out, leaving the café in stunned silence.
Anthony stared at the door long after she left, guilt crashing down like a wave. Amber sat in awkward silence, realizing perhaps too late that even innocent coffee dates had consequences when trust was already broken.
The Fallout
Later that day, Shayla packed a bag. Not forever, but long enough to clear her head. She needed space, clarity, and peace—the kind she couldn’t find while Anthony kept old flames flickering in the background.
Anthony tried calling. Texting. Begging for a chance to explain.
But Shayla let the silence speak for her.
Amber stayed away after that. Maybe it was guilt, or maybe she finally understood what she had taken part in.
The Truth
The truth was, Anthony hadn’t cheated—this time. But the emotional betrayal, the secrets, the disrespect of sneaking behind her back—that was enough to crack the foundation of their relationship.
And Shayla? She learned that day that sometimes walking away from what hurts is stronger than fighting to keep it alive.
As she sat alone in her friend’s guest room that night, Shayla sipped her own cup of coffee.
And for the first time in weeks, it tasted like freedom
Post a Comment